Blog Layout

Home Detention: Approved for Maricopa County in DUI Cases

Lawrence Koplow • July 27, 2020

Arizona has an incarceration problem. We incarcerate people at a higher rate than most other states and many other countries.

Incarcerating such a high rate of people comes with both a social and economic cost. To address these issues, several years ago the Arizona legislature passed a law that authorized a portion of a jail sentence to be served by house arrest.  In Arizona we call this “ home detention “, “ continuous alcohol monitoring ” or “ electronic monitoring .” However, home detention has not been available in all Arizona courts.

The coronavirus pandemic has brought a flaw in the program into public view and resulted in a remedy.

Arizona's Two Home Detention Statutes

Maricopa County Passes Home Detention

County Home Detention Law

The Arizona legislature passed A.R.S. § 11-251.15 .  This law authorized the county Board of Supervisors to approve a home detention program as a sentencing option in misdemeanor DUI cases. A home detention program allows a DUI defendant, following an initial mandatory period in custody, to serve the remainder of the sentence on home detention.

Municipal Home Detention Law

The Arizona legislature also passed A.R.S. § 9-499.07 . This statute is similar in almost every respect to its county counterpart – except as to what jurisdiction it pertains. It provides a city or town may establish a prisoner work, community restitution work and home detention program for eligible sentenced prisoners, which shall be treated the same as confinement in jail.

This statute required “[t]he presiding judge of the city or town municipal court shall approve the program before its implementation.”

Arizona Courts Home Detention

The Problem

DUI Penalties

Same Conviction Different Penalties

After the Arizona legislature passed both of these laws most courts implemented some form of a home detention program. However, there was one notable exception – Maricopa County . This created a system where people convicted of the same criminal offense (e.g. a DUI) receive dramatically different jail sentences.

Concurrent Jurisdiction

Maricopa County has numerous courts with overlapping jurisdiction.  The two kinds of courts with concurrent jurisdiction are called City Courts (municipal) and Justice Courts (county). For example, Desert Ridge Justice Court is within a sub-section the City of Phoenix. 

Overlapping Court Jurisiction Arizona

Arizona law permits an officer to submit citations to either the Desert Ridge Justice Court or the Phoenix Municipal Court. One court having home detention and the other does not. Thus, people prosecuted in city courts get home detention and people prosecuted in justice courts do not. 

The Different Jail Sentences

Let’s look at the jail math this system has created.

Phoenix Municipal Court:
Super-Extreme DUI Conviction

45 day mandatory minimum jail sentence

After all legally available sentencing reductions

  • 3 days initial jail
  • 11 home detention

Justice Court:
Super-Extreme DUI Conviction

45 day mandatory minimum jail sentence

After all legally available sentencing reductions

  • 14 days jail

Municipal Courts with Home Detention

Justice Courts Receiving Home Detention

  • Phoenix Municipal Court
  • Scottsdale City Court
  • Gilbert Municipal Court
  • Mesa Municipal Court
  • Tempe Municipal Court
  • Glendale Municipal Court
  • Fountain Hills Municipal Court
  • Chandler Municipal Court
  • Agua Fria Justice Court
  • Arcadia Biltmore Justice Court
  • Arrowhead Justice Court
  • Country Meadows Justice Court
  • Desert Ridge Justice Court
  • Dreamy Draw Justice Court
  • East Mesa Justice Court
  • Encanto Justice Court
  • Hassayampa Justice Court
  • Highland Justice Court
  • Ironwood Justice Court
  • Kyrene Justice Court
  • Manistee Justice Court
  • Maryvale Justice Court
  • McDowell Mountain Justice Court
  • Moon Valley Justice Court
  • North Mesa Justice Court
  • San Marcos Justice Court
  • San Tan Justice Court
  • South Mountain Justice Court
  • University Lakes Justice Court
  • West McDowell Justice Court
  • West Mesa Justice Court
  • White Tank Justice Court

The New Maricopa County Home Detention Program

In response to the Covid-19 pandemic, on July 22, 2020, the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors voted to implement a home detention program. Details of the program are still unavailable.  However, it is expected to be implemented at some point in August of this year.

Lawrence Koplow Signature

Related:

Reported Result vs. Complete Result

By Lawrence Koplow • September 9, 2020
The reported results of a BAC test in DUI cases appear to provide the answer we are seeking: how much ethanol is in a person’s blood.  However, let’s look at the fine print. The Reported Results A machine called a gas chromatograph is used to measure an alcohol concentration in blood samples.   The measurement, which […] The post Reported Result vs. Complete Result appeared first on Lawrence Koplow: Arizona DUI Attorney | Phoenix & Scottsdale.

A Legal Bandwidth Problem

By Lawrence Koplow • September 5, 2020
The appearance of science can become the appearance of truth - even when the junk science is employed. Do we provide enough bandwidth to debunk these unreliable scientific claims? The post A Legal Bandwidth Problem appeared first on Lawrence Koplow: Arizona DUI Attorney | Phoenix & Scottsdale.

Measuring and Counting | Forensic Science

By Lawrence Koplow • August 27, 2020
Measuring is different from counting. However, in forensic science the two are often suggested to be the same. This needs to change. MEASURING Measuring is the assignment of a number, and all the uncertainties of that of that number, to something.  The purpose of assigning a number is to give meaning to the object measured. […] The post Measuring and Counting | Forensic Science appeared first on Lawrence Koplow: Arizona DUI Attorney | Phoenix & Scottsdale.

Give a shit?

By Lawrence Koplow • August 23, 2020
What Do You Give a Shit About? You probably haven’t really considered the question. Finding the answer is not as easy as it may seem. Looking inward is uncomfortable. Self-examination requires courage. It may also demand change. Once you see what you really give a shit about – you can’t unsee it. Once you define […] The post Give a shit? appeared first on Lawrence Koplow: Arizona DUI Attorney | Phoenix & Scottsdale.

Validity of Consent To Search | Vermont v. Weisler

By Lawrence Koplow • August 10, 2020
The Vermont Supreme Court holds xx The Constitutional Question xx The Legal Answer(s)  A xx  majority opinion reversed the appellate court decision finding: xx xx XX The Facts Traffic Stop A Vermont state trooper monitoring traffic on an Interstate.  He observed a vehicle traveling northbound without its rear license plate illuminated. The officer stopped the […] The post Validity of Consent To Search | Vermont v. Weisler appeared first on Lawrence Koplow: Arizona DUI Attorney | Phoenix & Scottsdale.

Esketamine DUI: How is it Different than Ketamine?

By Lawrence Koplow • August 5, 2020
Esketamine Drug DUI Cases Will Become An Issue in Arizona It is well established that Depression is a common and serious health problem. According to the World Health Organization the disease affects more than 264 million people. Common Depression Treatments Depression treatments typically include antidepressant medications that fall in a class of drugs known as […] The post Esketamine DUI: How is it Different than Ketamine? appeared first on Lawrence Koplow: Arizona DUI Attorney | Phoenix & Scottsdale.

9 Facts About Arizona’s Recreational Marijuana Initiative (2020)

By Lawrence Koplow • July 21, 2020
In the November 2020 election, a restricted use of recreational marijuana will be on Arizona voter’s ballots. The ballot initiative essentially decriminalizes possession and use of small amounts of cannabis. Currently, possession of marijuana is a felony in Arizona. This initiative would end such prosecutions. Arizona’s Marijuana initiative is titled the Smart and Safe Arizona […] The post 9 Facts About Arizona’s Recreational Marijuana Initiative (2020) appeared first on Lawrence Koplow: Arizona DUI Attorney | Phoenix & Scottsdale.

Bostock v. Clayton County Summary

By Lawrence Koplow • June 26, 2020
Justice Gorsuch authored the majority opinion The Legal Question Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits employment discrimination based on sex.  Does this mean the statute prohibits discrimination based on an individual’s sexual orientation? The Legal Answer Yes.  Employers who fire employees for being gay or transgender violates Title VII of the […] The post Bostock v. Clayton County
Summary appeared first on Lawrence Koplow: Arizona DUI Attorney | Phoenix & Scottsdale.

Strength and Compassion of Batman [Updated 2020]

By Lawrence Koplow • May 2, 2020
Sometimes, what you need, is found in the last place you would ever expect it. When a teenage kid is caught in the middle of trying to steal the tires off the Batmobile you expect something to happen. You expect Batman to dispense his brand of “justice”.   https://youtu.be/7sVDEXfMdXo However, maybe his idea of justice […] The post Strength and Compassion of Batman [Updated 2020] appeared first on Lawrence Koplow: Arizona DUI Attorney | Phoenix & Scottsdale.

Coronavirus Timeline

By Lawrence Koplow • March 30, 2020
The coronavirus is impacting every aspect of our lives. The criminal justice system has no immunity.  As this crisis continues, and for a long time to follow, those going through the justice system will need the government’s help. When these requests face resistance, we must show many of the consequences for which relief is sought, […] The post Coronavirus Timeline appeared first on Lawrence Koplow: Arizona DUI Attorney | Phoenix & Scottsdale.
More Posts
Share by: